Skip to main

News

TTAB Rules Tribal Immunity No Bar to TM Cancellations

24 September 2026

In a case of first impression, the TTAB held that the defense of tribal sovereign immunity is unavailable in Board cancellation proceedings. The decision came in Philip Morris USA Inc. v. IP Services International Inc. and Sycuan Tribal Development Corporation, where Philip Morris sought to cancel four tobacco-related marks.

The Board applied reasoning from prior cases denying tribal immunity in patent challenges and state immunity in trademark matters. It concluded that the administrative nature of TTAB proceedings supports allowing such challenges to proceed despite the transfer of marks to a tribal entity.

The unsigned precedential opinion rejected arguments distinguishing the situation and aligned with federal policy favoring review of trademark validity. The ruling clarifies that parties cannot use tribal transfers to evade cancellation petitions at the Board.

This development affects strategies involving assignment of marks to immune entities and underscores the TTAB's role in maintaining the integrity of the federal trademark register.

Sources: https://www.law360.com/articles/2527543/tribal-immunity-cannot-block-tm-challenges-ttab-rules https://news.bloomberglaw.com/ip-law/philip-morris-trademark-attack-not-stymied-by-tribal-immunity

Share