Skip to main

News

TTAB Holds Tribal Immunity No Bar to TM Cancellation Proceedings

28 September 2026

In Philip Morris USA Inc. v. IP Services International Inc. and Sycuan Tribal Development Corporation, the TTAB denied a motion to dismiss a cancellation petition based on tribal sovereign immunity. The Board determined that a tribe or tribal entity owning a federal trademark registration cannot invoke immunity to prevent TTAB review of whether the mark belongs on the register.

The September 18, 2026, order addressed a question of first impression. It drew on precedents rejecting tribal immunity in patent challenges and state immunity in trademark matters. The ruling applies specifically to administrative inter partes proceedings before the Board.

The decision leaves the underlying claims of abandonment and naked licensing undecided. Proceedings remain suspended pending further reports on discovery, and Philip Morris must still prove statutory grounds for cancellation.

The holding is limited and does not eliminate tribal immunity in other contexts or decide whether the respondent qualified as an arm of the tribe.

Share