Skip to main

News

PepsiCo Asks Supreme Court to Treat TM Strength as Legal Question

7 November 2026

PepsiCo Inc. urged the U.S. Supreme Court on November 6, 2026, to deny review in a case that would determine whether the inherent strength of a trademark is a question of law for judges or a question of fact for juries. The petition responds to an appeal from Rise Brewing Co. in the long-running dispute over the RISE marks and MTN DEW RISE ENERGY drink.

The Second Circuit treated inherent strength as carrying a legal element, allowing summary judgment for PepsiCo after finding the marks weak as a matter of law. PepsiCo argues that strength determinations are quintessentially legal and best resolved by courts.

The petition addresses a circuit split on the issue. A grant of certiorari could standardize the treatment of the conceptual-strength factor in likelihood-of-confusion analyses nationwide.

Sources: https://www.law360.com/articles/2547393/pepsi-urges-high-court-to-leave-tm-strength-to-judges https://www.dlapiper.com/insights/publications/intellectual-property-news/2026/supreme-court-takes-up-trademark-strength

Share