News
Ninth Circuit Reverses Winery Win in Bandido TM Dispute
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit on October 29, 2026 reversed a district court’s grant of summary judgment to Sutter Home Winery Inc. in a trademark dispute with Roar Spirits LLC.
Roar Spirits sought to register EL BANDIDO YANKEE and a composite mark for tequila. Sutter Home opposed the applications, arguing likelihood of confusion with its BANDIT mark for boxed wine. The TTAB sided with Sutter Home, and the Northern District of California granted summary judgment upholding that decision.
The Ninth Circuit panel held that a reasonable factfinder could conclude the marks are dissimilar in appearance, sound, meaning and overall commercial impression. It noted the added words and syllables in Roar’s marks, differences in product presentation, and survey evidence of no actual confusion. The court remanded the case for further proceedings.
The unpublished decision underscores that consumer confusion remains a fact-intensive question rarely resolved on summary judgment in the Ninth Circuit.