Skip to main

News

Fourth Circuit Affirms Grin Trademark Priority Ruling

19 November 2026

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit on November 18 affirmed a district-court decision that preserved U.S. priority for San Diego-based Sacks Holdings Inc., doing business as Grin Oral Care, over a New Zealand company's use of the GRIN mark for dental floss. Grin Natural USA Ltd. argued that its 2017 online sales to U.S. customers established earlier rights, but the court held that the two small, unsolicited transactions did not constitute continuous use in commerce sufficient to claim priority.

The dispute arose when the New Zealand firm sought to enforce its mark against the U.S. company. The lower court found that Sacks Holdings had established priority through its own use, and the Fourth Circuit agreed that the isolated foreign sales failed to meet the statutory requirements for priority. The unpublished decision reinforces the strict continuous-use standard applied to foreign trademark claimants seeking U.S. rights.

The ruling leaves the U.S. company free to continue marketing its GRIN-branded floss products without interference from the New Zealand mark on priority grounds. No further appeals were noted in the decision.

Sources: https://news.bloomberglaw.com/ip-law/dental-floss-company-retains-use-of-grin-trademark-on-appeal https://trademarksupport.com/news/

Share