Skip to main

News

Canadian Federal Court Bars New Evidence in Trademark Appeal

1 October 2026

On September 29, 2026, the Federal Court of Canada dismissed a motion by Bonafide Health, LLC seeking to introduce new evidence and conduct cross-examination in its appeal of a Trademark Opposition Board decision.

The Board had rejected Bonafide Health, LLC's opposition to an application by Bonafide Health & Drugs Limited for the mark BONAFIDE & Design. The Board found insufficient evidence of prior use or reputation in Canada for the opponent's marks.

The Court ruled that parties cannot use an appeal to obtain a second opportunity to cross-examine affiants or introduce new affidavits that could have been presented earlier. It further held that the proposed new evidence would not have materially affected the Board's decision.

The decision reinforces that trademark opposition parties must present their best evidence, including any cross-examinations, during Board proceedings. Additional evidence on appeal is admitted only if it would likely change the outcome. Costs were awarded to the applicant.

Sources: https://www.mondaq.com/canada/trademark/1848200/federal-court-rejects-new-evidence-in-trademark-appeal https://www.ippractice.ca/blog/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/2026-FC-1144.pdf

Share