News
7th Circuit Affirms Minimal Statutory Damages in Counterfeiting Case
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit has affirmed a district court’s award of the statutory minimum damages in a trademark counterfeiting and cybersquatting case. Plaintiff Shenzhen Huajie Technology Co. Ltd., operating as bellelily, sued Shenzhen Leyibei Technology Co. Ltd. over use of a similar domain and sale of comparable clothing items. After the defendant defaulted, the Northern District of Illinois entered judgment for the plaintiff but awarded only $1,000 for counterfeiting and $1,000 for cybersquatting rather than the maximum statutory amounts sought.
On appeal, the Seventh Circuit held that a default judgment alone does not automatically entitle a plaintiff to enhanced statutory damages. The court noted that the plaintiff had not provided sufficient contemporaneous evidence or argument to support a higher award at the time the district court considered the request. The panel emphasized that district courts retain discretion in setting damages even after default, provided the award falls within the statutory range.
The decision clarifies the evidentiary burden on Lanham Act plaintiffs seeking maximum statutory damages following default. It underscores that while defaults establish liability, plaintiffs must still support requests for enhanced remedies with evidence of willfulness or other aggravating factors. The ruling leaves the injunction in place but rejects the request to increase monetary relief.
Sources: https://www.law360.com/cases/68d1781d15208091c81e51e6/articles https://www.casemine.com/commentary/us/default-is-not-damages-proof%3A-lanham-act-plaintiffs-must-support-enhanced-statutory-damages-after-default/view